This loop is in Gmaj scale with different chord progression (best sounding ones have been chosen). This is just for comparison with Fmaj scale (my previous loop https://audiosex.pro/threads/my-new-tune.21228/).

Please tell your sensation when comparing them. Which is more melodious to you? I'd choose Fmaj. It's lovelier. I don't claim that one scale is better than the other but I personally think that some scales are melodic than others.

Thanks so much again!



The link:
https://www.mediafire.com/?2smicm4q3dkcmwk

 

Last edited by a moderator: Oct 15, 2015

You should really study a bit about harmony, how chords work... and until you do, just remove them completely from your music. You're keeping them low in the mix because in a way, you know they sound wrong but your intelect is forcing you to include "theoretical" devices that you don't understand yet.

Your posts are all very similar. When you're writing the key, the chords and telling people what they should feel and think about your piece... something isn't right with what you're doing and you know it, you just don't want to acknowledge it and end up overcompensating.

Not trying to be mean, just offering honest help.