AS a piano player i spend a lot of time searching and trying MIDI keyboard to fit well with my sensation.
That's all about sensation and is the first reason to understand the subjectivity of the problem.

What i can't resume for answer your question in an objective way (and of course not knowing anything about how you feel with the different keyboard) is :

- Be aware of the fact that your playing style can adapt to a lot of keyboard, and that's a reason why it's easier to find a keyboard not so good than your new one.

- Try the keyboard using fatar semi weighted keys because they are often good, having a nice "ivory feel", a good and precise dynamic response (important for piano and strings for example), and robust for not moving left to right (speaking about the keys) like a toy.

Example of keyboards : novation SL line, komplete kontrol and of course the fatar studiologic

- With the time a prefer use electric piano keyboard using their midi connection.
Of course they don't have pad or fader but for the price that's the cheapest way to get goods keys

Examples : Korg B2, Korg SP 140, casio CDP, etc.