I never said that. Surely never said either that add9 would be the same as add 2. Neither the second or the ninth are at the base structure of the...
As I've said, that kind of chart is common and it's not supposed to be related to key signatures. It's used to transpose the intervals of a scale...
Dude... since when is doubling octaves from the base structure considered an addition? You 're confusing things. Edit: Cm add 9 has no 7th,...
I've already acknowledge that within the harmonic context (tonality), intervals have "their own place". What I said is that to the context of the...
I see I've won a "dumb" award :bleh: Am I supposed to click that on every dumb and uninformed post that this topic has? :rofl:
Well.. no. That's called "voicing". Example: You don't write that a chord has "R - b3 - 5 - b10 - 12", that is redundant. The structure is...
That is a totally different subject (the position of intervals inside a tonal framework). I think that given the subject, all that matters here is...
Yes but that is the problem of "confusion", nothing more than that. The sound, harmonically or melodically, will be exactly the same. In other...
I don't understand how does that relate to harmony and how it would be different. Don't you mean "enharmonic equivalent"?
The main problem with note naming isn't really about notes sounding different since we are all using the 12TET system to divide the octave. F#...
And BTW, no one who actually learns how to analyze and understand music will ever say "I learnt all that but then I decided I didn't need it"....
Music has no fingers or keys. If you know how to count to 7 and start relating what you hear to the appropriate numbers (with the appropriate...
Absolute note names are totally irrelevant to music.. which is why the math exercise with the note names is also useless (to music). It's all in...
I am looking at lots of superfluous musical maths. You can have fun with that stuff but that should come AFTER you have the foundations down.. or...
When you know it "correctly" you realize you don't have to memorize scales, shapes or whatever. When you really know things in a theoretical way,...
Music theory isn't about right or wrong.. just like a map has no right or wrong places. Another common misconception. If you want to limit...
That is what I said, "drawing a map". Not the same as "buying a map". But it is true, non-theory people always get too defensive because they...
Without somekind of theory it is like exploring the world without ever drawing a map. You'll keep visiting the same places thinking it's the first...
In theory those aren't extensions to the chord, they are already part of the chord. A 10th is the 3rd and the 12th is the 5th so they don't...
@foster911 Dude, just stop. You're all over the place with music theory and possibly getting other people confused too. You're totally thinking...
Separate names with a comma.
