We will never get out of this circle if you reply me everytime I answer someonelse. :rofl: This time I won't comment on that. :like:
Once and for all.. 880Hz, harmonics, consonance, dissonance, etc... those are facts. Grab an osciloscope and watch. MIDI, Staff Notation, MP3,...
Now seriously: If you can practice and be good at ear training without any theory, that's already a huge thing.. I just don't know how you'll...
Let me just add this: 10.000 hours of NO theory studying means nothing if you cant write anything and just write boring scales with no substance....
Judgin by this thread I wouldn't be so positive about it.. I am sure most people that watch the video will tell themselves "ok, just like the...
I understand that and people who understand what theory is will get it too. Now put yourself in the place of someone who might be "on the fence"...
...and back to zero. :facepalm: The frequencies/harmonics/consonance/dissonance/etc part isn't what we use as theory either. Again, that's the...
You seem too close minded to understand that one thing doesn't mean that the other can't/shouldn't be done. If my words intimidate you in some...
Some genres have very "shallow" theoretical concepts compared to others. By now even your dog knows about the 12 bars, I IV V in blues but OTOH...
You make it sound like there's One theory.. and that is usually part of the problem in understanding what it is and what it is for. Theory can be...
Notation (or any representation) = facts, it represents pitches along a timeline. There's zero theory on that.
The MIDI file or the mp3 of that same piece of music will yeld the same theory or lack of it. Theory is in the theorizer, not in the subject...
I understand the analogy but I am sure that "predictable outcomes" will be misinterpreted by the anti-mob in a way that does more harm than good....
Don't agree with any of that. Sheet music is a notation system. Works just like MIDI info but it's much less accurate, which is understandable...
What? ...and I am fan of millionares..?
Sorry, I can't answer to any of that because everything you wrote are just examples of what I said, despite the "it depends" expression. Maybe you...
Throwing names is something that ALWAYS happens in these threads and it's totally meaningless. Some people never went past 4th grade in school...
You could've just said "I'm an anti", no need for the invalid arguments.
Not really. What you're saying is more about fact than theory. Besides, misunderstanding number 2 would be precisely that music theory is about...
Of course not. Nobody needs to play instruments or write music either.
Separate names with a comma.
