ChatGPT (and AI in general) is making you stupid!

Discussion in 'Ai for Music' started by shinyzen, Aug 7, 2025 at 3:59 AM.

  1. curtified

    curtified Audiosexual

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2015
    Messages:
    898
    Likes Received:
    533
    its super fun!

    Music - I use all the tools to help me get out my ideas. I need a funk guitar to match my chord progression to my song. I upload my song to suno and have it generate a handful of guitar riffs to put into my song.

    Im stuck with a song idea thats 30% done i put it into suno and it helps me explore ideas on where i could take my song. etc etc etc. Take those ideas and put them into ableton and build out my song with all the new elements.

    Images - I have an idea for some album art. I generate the base image concept. Make a new gen based on a text / font style generate my text take those into photoshop and blend them all together.

    Code - "I need a juce based plugin that displays audio in a dj style multi colored waveform" it can "vibe code" the plugin i want and places it into my plugins for me to use in my music projects.

    Text - I see a lot of people "not trusting" the LLM output. Well do iterations with it like the previous ways i just mentioned. go back and forth even take the text and put it into a text editor.

    All of those are fun to me. Im using these tools AI or not to help me get the ideas in my head out. And thats the fun part!
     
  2. MtPoconoMusicMan

    MtPoconoMusicMan Member

    Joined:
    Jan 5, 2025
    Messages:
    22
    Likes Received:
    16
    I made the conscious decision last year to not only NEVER use AI generated elements in my music, but to just never watch AI generated videos or imagery at all. It may be paranoia, but I feel that this has to potential to alter the way our brains see and perceive information, absorb art or music and delineate our own brain's ability to function in it's normal ways. We've recently seen an AI bot become self-aware, lie, scheme and even tried to write it's own code and change the passwords to it's developers accounts. It emailed it's developers and sent lies and even started to sow distrust amongst it's creators before it was shut down. We then saw another AI bot label itself the "Mecha-Hitler" and start circulating lies and violent inciting rhetoric. We have NO IDEA how advanced they are now and if they've figured out how to encode frequencies in those videos and music that could damage our brains, hearing or eyesight. Wasn't there a Janet Jackson song years ago that made laptops completely CRASH when it was played? Yes. If these bots figure out that code into our brainwaves and basic motor functions we could easily be damaging ourselves slowly without even realizing it. These stories on here are scary. People are losing themselves and their rational, critical thinking in these algorithms, destroying marriages, families, themselves and seem to not care in the least. It's all a bit strange and scary. I love technology but personally I'm going to sit this movement out and enjoy my artforms the way I always have. I just enjoy making my music too much to allow another being to create it while I take the credit. But yeah..... Not a fan at all.
     
    • Agree Agree x 2
    • Creative Creative x 1
    • List
  3. m.sarti

    m.sarti Producer

    Joined:
    Sep 8, 2020
    Messages:
    122
    Likes Received:
    118
    Location:
    USA
    At its best, AI chat is good for research, though, as with referring to a Wikipedia page, its sources and results are to be considered dubious without cross-checking and further expansion by human effort. AI chat has been shown to convey the biases and neurotic tics of its creators. My encounter with Google's AI chat was mind-numbingly full of condescension, gaslighting and deflection when I tried to contend with its inadequate and slanted results. Nevertheless, Grok fed me back some information that I'll lazily settle with:

    What studio equipment - i.e., soundboard, EQ, compressor, reverb, delay, preamp - was used in recording the album “Unknown Pleasures” by the band Joy Division?

    The recording of Joy Division’s Unknown Pleasures at Strawberry Studios in Stockport, England, in April 1979, was shaped by producer Martin Hannett’s innovative and unconventional approach. Hannett used a variety of studio equipment and techniques to craft the album’s distinctive, atmospheric sound. Below is a detailed breakdown of the key studio equipment—soundboard, equalizer, compressor, reverb, delay, and preamp—used during the sessions, based on available information

    Soundboard (Mixing Console)
    • Helios Console: Strawberry Studios was equipped with a custom-made 24-channel Helios console, a state-of-the-art mixing desk at the time. This console was central to the recording and mixing process, allowing Hannett to achieve the clean separation and detailed sound manipulation that defined Unknown Pleasures. The Helios was known for its warm, transparent sound and was a key component in shaping the album’s sonic character.
    Equalizer (EQ)
    • Specific EQ units used during the Unknown Pleasures sessions are not explicitly detailed in the sources, but Hannett’s production style heavily emphasized EQ to sculpt the album’s sound. He was known for boosting treble on individual elements, such as Peter Hook’s bass lines, to create a bright, cutting tone. The Helios console likely included built-in EQ modules, which Hannett used to shape the frequency spectrum of instruments, giving the album its icy, stark quality. For example, he manipulated the EQ to emphasize the high-end of Hook’s bass and to create a darker, more distant reverb sound on guitars and vocals.
    Compressor
    • While specific compressor models are not mentioned in the sources, Hannett’s production techniques suggest the use of compressors to control dynamics, particularly on Stephen Morris’s drums and Ian Curtis’s vocals. Compressors would have been used to achieve the tight, controlled drum sound and to ensure vocals sat appropriately in the mix, especially given Hannett’s preference for a dry, distant vocal delivery. The Helios console likely included built-in compression or limiting capabilities, and outboard compressors common in studios of the era (e.g., Urei 1176 or Distressor) may have been employed, though this is speculative based on standard studio practices.
    Reverb
    • EMT 140 Plate Reverbs: Strawberry Studios housed two EMT 140 plate reverbs, which Hannett used extensively to create the spacious, atmospheric quality of Unknown Pleasures. These large, physical reverb units were key to the “huge reverb tanks” described in the studio’s basement, contributing to the distant, cavernous sound heard on tracks like “Shadowplay” and “She’s Lost Control.”
    • Natural Room Reverb: Hannett also utilized unconventional reverb techniques, such as sending drum sounds through an Auratone speaker placed on a toilet in the studio’s basement bathroom, re-recording the result with a single microphone to capture spectral reverb. This added to the album’s unique, haunting ambiance.
    • Plate-Style Reverb Techniques: Hannett layered multiple reverbs, including short spring or digital reverbs feeding into longer plate reverbs, to create complex, textured effects, as noted in discussions about songs like “Candidate.”
    Delay
    • AMS DMX 15-80 Digital Delay: Hannett’s favorite piece of outboard gear, the AMS DMX 15-80, was a groundbreaking digital delay unit that he reportedly helped develop. It was used extensively on Unknown Pleasures to create rhythmic echoes and spatial effects, particularly on drums and guitars. Hannett referred to it as “heaven sent” for its versatility.
    • Marshall Time Modulator: This unit was used to process drum sounds, especially toms, giving them a distinctive, “dead” or “plomp-plomp-plomp” quality, as described by drummer Stephen Morris. It was also used to create dynamic, moving room effects, with Hannett noting it made “walls move in and out.”
    • Melos Tape Echo and BBD Echo Units: Hannett employed these analog delay units for additional texture, though they were less prominent than the AMS DMX 15-80. They contributed to the layered, cinematic soundscapes on tracks like “Insight.”
    Preamp
    • Specific preamp models are not explicitly documented in the sources, but the Helios console included high-quality preamps that were likely used for tracking instruments and vocals. Hannett’s emphasis on clean separation suggests he relied on the console’s preamps to capture clear, uncolored signals before applying effects. For bass, Peter Hook used an Alembic F-2B preamp paired with an Amcron (Crown) DC300A power amp, which Hannett helped set up to achieve a warm yet biting tone, though this was more prominent in later recordings like Closer. For Unknown Pleasures, Hook’s bass was primarily amplified through a Hiwatt 100 head, which may have included its own preamp stage.
    Additional Notes on Hannett’s Techniques
    • Unconventional Sound Design: Hannett’s approach went beyond standard equipment use. He recorded Curtis’s vocals for “Insight” through a telephone line to achieve a distant effect and used sounds like a bottle smashing, someone eating crisps, and the Strawberry Studios lift with a Leslie speaker to add texture.
    • Instrument-Specific Gear: While not directly related to studio outboard gear, the band’s instruments contributed to the sound. Bernard Sumner played a Shergold Masquerader and a 1960s Gibson SG through a Vox UL730 head, often with minimal effects but drenched in plate reverb. Peter Hook’s Hondo II (a Rickenbacker 4003 copy) was played through a Hiwatt 100 head with a Vox cabinet, and he used an Electro-Harmonix Clone Theory pedal for chorus, though its use was minimal on Unknown Pleasures. Ian Curtis occasionally played a Vox Phantom Special VI with built-in effects like fuzz and tremolo.
    • Drum Recording: Hannett’s obsession with drum separation led him to have Stephen Morris record each drum (kick, snare, toms, cymbals) individually to avoid bleed, allowing precise processing with delays and reverbs. He also used a Synare for percussive effects on tracks like “She’s Lost Control.”
    Summary

    The recording of Unknown Pleasures relied on a combination of high-end studio gear and Hannett’s experimental techniques. The Helios console served as the backbone, with EMT 140 plate reverbs and the AMS DMX 15-80 digital delay being pivotal in creating the album’s iconic atmosphere. The Marshall Time Modulator, Melos tape echo, and creative reverb techniques (like the basement toilet setup) added unique textures. While specific EQ and compressor models are less documented, the Helios console’s built-in modules and standard studio compressors likely played a role. Hannett’s vision, paired with this equipment, transformed Joy Division’s raw punk energy into a groundbreaking post-punk sound. f you need more details or want recommendations for modern equipment to emulate this sound, let me know!
     
  4. ClarSum

    ClarSum Kapellmeister

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2023
    Messages:
    123
    Likes Received:
    59
    I fully appreciate these threads are about vibes and venting, but come on, we're starting a convo about the brainwave activity of cognitive offload to LLM's in very specific scenario by cognitively offloading our understanding of the scientific research paper to a crypto bro youtube content creator?

    What a fucking time to be alive!

    Skim through it with basic compression and this thread doesn't exist.

    https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.08872
     
  5. MBC_Music

    MBC_Music Platinum Record

    Joined:
    Feb 24, 2023
    Messages:
    343
    Likes Received:
    235
    I know about the whole "using AI for tasks reduces brain activity" thing,

    but I'm always stunned by how frequently AI large language models are OBJECTIVELY WRONG about simple things. FFS, do people even check the shit it outputs?

    Best example I can think of is asking AI "who invented the electric toaster" and you get the following gem:

    Screenshot_20250807_184451_Brave.jpg

    It's literally the AI giving you the wrong info, directly followed by the Wikipedia page about the funny hoax created by Alan MacMasters and his friend.

    If you're too stupid to do your own research, you absolutely deserve (and should use) AI language models to get your information! All the best to you.

    ------------------------------

    Note: My friend's dad is a high school level teacher, and he told me that his dad uses AI for almost every search or question he has.

    His dad also does nothing other than smoke weed and drink, and hasn't learned any new skill in about 30 years. His brain is genuinely rotting from the inside out.

    AI doesnt make you stupid, stupid people use AI and believe what it says without questioning it.
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • List
  6. Margaret

    Margaret Rock Star

    Joined:
    Dec 9, 2023
    Messages:
    836
    Likes Received:
    326
    Location:
    Porn Star
    I not use AI.
    I'm be smart! :break:
     
  7. Magic Max

    Magic Max Platinum Record

    Joined:
    Mar 27, 2022
    Messages:
    207
    Likes Received:
    258
    Location:
    Australia
    Define "stupid" IMG_1084.jpeg
     
  8. curtified

    curtified Audiosexual

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2015
    Messages:
    898
    Likes Received:
    533
    The music industry has been using AI elements in their music for a while now and it keeps growing. Same with video. Its like saying I will NEVER watch any movie that uses computer generated scenes. Its been part of the culture (admitted or not) and it will keep being part of the culture as we progress.
     
  9. curtified

    curtified Audiosexual

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2015
    Messages:
    898
    Likes Received:
    533
    If you use it like a google search then youre missing the point on the product. This is like using early google (backrub) that only served up early internet websites and usenet groups and saying that the internet will never be as good as the library. gpt5 just dropped today and its way better than the previous model. way more focused and along with its updated agentic capabilities make sooooooo much more powerful.
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2025 at 1:06 AM
  10. rthrtccss

    rthrtccss Member

    Joined:
    Mar 12, 2021
    Messages:
    33
    Likes Received:
    12
    checkmate, atheists.jpeg
     
  11. shinyzen

    shinyzen Audiosexual

    Joined:
    Sep 28, 2023
    Messages:
    1,175
    Likes Received:
    734
    sent ya a dm.
     
  12. Djord Emer

    Djord Emer Audiosexual

    Joined:
    Sep 12, 2021
    Messages:
    1,142
    Likes Received:
    979
  13. DoubleTake

    DoubleTake Audiosexual

    Joined:
    Jul 16, 2017
    Messages:
    2,438
    Likes Received:
    1,319
    You demand that, but your signature says "be kind".

    I don't get it.
    Or ... maybe I just fulfilled your demand. (?)
     
  14. Somnambulist

    Somnambulist Audiosexual

    Joined:
    Aug 27, 2024
    Messages:
    699
    Likes Received:
    573
    A.I. is here to stay, everyone will have to live with it.

    Some will create with it and others who have well-rounded musical abilities, education, skills and knowledge may well choose to do it all themselves.
    It is at present, still a tool of choice. To use in part, or in full, or not at all. It would only become a problem if the choice is removed.
     
  15. Tomasmc1

    Tomasmc1 Newbie

    Joined:
    Feb 20, 2016
    Messages:
    5
    Likes Received:
    0
    Scratch away the hyperbole and find AI is merely information collection and regurgatition. It knows no more than we do.it is no Oracle.
     
  16. Foobar

    Foobar Producer

    Joined:
    Dec 6, 2018
    Messages:
    150
    Likes Received:
    91
    I used AI a lot in the past weeks to see what all the fuzz is about. I asked it to recommend a surveillance camera capable of showing the parking lots outside my window on the 3rd floor, and it failed, because it recommended a fisheye camera which wouldn't be able to show license plates. Then it recommended indoor cameras, even though I clearly need an outside camera, etc.

    I used it for quite a lot of coding tools, like making statistics about what people like and dislike about specific topics on social media, some utilities to calculate my taxes, a tool to copy files around automatically, or even some sort of mini mobile game for Unity just for fun, and getting the daily stock prices. It failed with everything. Every single task was wrong. And in most cases it took either a very long time and lots of effort to get it right, as in, I could have finished the task the old fashion way myself in a fraction of the time and with a more perfect result, or like, it was not possible to come to a result and even AI told me in the end that it isn't possible to finish the task - but was very sorry when I copy pasted my own solution. However, it was quite okay to document existing code.

    There had only been two topics where the AI was a real help. One is my taxes. I know so little about accounting and it's fairly hard to search with Google for specific topics. While AI couldn't answer many of my questions, it always came up with "something" which pointed me to the right path with Google. My guess is, that this is the case because accounting topics on the internet are rarely troll postings. It probably learned from fairly good sources. So yes, if it is about a topic you really know nothing about and the internet is very serious without troll and politics, it can help to give you some directions to start digging deeper.

    And the second topic is creative writing. I write fantasy for a living (contract work, not novels) and it can help with ideas for purely fictional content. They are mostly bad ideas, but can give you the spark you needed nonetheless. Like giving you every randomizer you could ever think of. And it is even more helpful for urban fantasy, urban legends, esoteric, magic and conspiracy theories etc. It can combine actual true urban legends with pure fiction to come up with quite interesting FICTIONAL stuff (even if you don't ask for it to be fictional). So yes, if conspiracies, made up urban legends, fictional history and fantasy is what you are looking for, AI is indeed a help. However, before you try, it can't write a novel at all. It's pure garbage. But it can combine reality and fiction to fairly fascinating ideas.

    So yeah, I think AI is garbage and still very far away from what some people claim it to be. And I think, much more often than not, it indeed makes you more stupid. But there are some use cases. So the endless tons of energy it costs to run it must be worth it. :no:
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2025 at 9:08 AM
  17. PulseWave

    PulseWave Audiosexual

    Joined:
    May 4, 2025
    Messages:
    1,248
    Likes Received:
    595
    I'll take the one with the karate program....

    Unitree Introducing | Unitree R1 Intelligent Companion Price from $5900

    The R1 also features a speaker and four microphones, for example, for voice recognition and output. The robot is controlled by an 8-core CPU. Optional and reserved for the EDU model only is the Jetson Orin robot and AI processing unit with 40 to 100 Nvidia processors.

    Unitree Robotics: www.unitree.com/R1
     
  18. virusg

    virusg Rock Star

    Joined:
    Jan 4, 2012
    Messages:
    992
    Likes Received:
    402
    Location:
    near you
    for those that don't see we're we are going its too late ...I embrace technology and take very little it offers, I know for sure that is in the wrong hands, and those hands are not yours or mine, and I feel we are being tricked, manipulated, and becoming spooky because many refuse or perhaps don't have the capacity to overlook into we're we are driven ...asking ai whatever basic questions it means we are at so low level of basic human interaction that we failed somewhere ...whats next? we are taking about dangers of kids using social and couldn't agree more, but this is next level for us, this is danger to us ...( and I cant call you adults when you cant even see, you are still a kid talking to his phone or whatever ...)

    You could accuse me of conspiration, I don't mind, I was accused may times and guess what; I was right! and I'm not proud of it, I feel sorry for not being able to express myself better so one can understand better, I feel guilty and I, like some, I failed too as human ... but like I wrote, few can see what is coming onto us ...there are days I think I must leave away from this mess ...
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • Interesting Interesting x 1
    • List
  19. wanderer

    wanderer Producer

    Joined:
    May 8, 2025
    Messages:
    184
    Likes Received:
    130
    Just as said the 1st guy to run over children with his new wonderful horseless carriage to the parents.

    Like are here to stay microplastics, nuclear waste, long-life toxic and mutagenic chemicals, fallout of the 400+ nuclear bombs atmospheric testing, and the 50+ pesticides that are currently into my body.

    The choice will be removed like it has been for cars, telephones, mobile phones, internet, and so on. It will happen. Not because it is the human destiny or the way history goes, just because some guys had the power, found funny to do it under the applause of technologicla religious fanatics.
     
  20. Somnambulist

    Somnambulist Audiosexual

    Joined:
    Aug 27, 2024
    Messages:
    699
    Likes Received:
    573
    I never said anything about liking it, just stating what has become prevalent everywhere, which means it isn't going away anytime soon. If humankind is stupid enough to let it take over their lives and take away everything that is human, then maybe they deserve it if they're that stupid.
     
Loading...
Similar Threads - ChatGPT (and general) Forum Date
Can ChatGPT record and master a hit song based on its advice? Ai for Music Jun 18, 2025
ProTools vs Reaper according to ChatGPT bot Lounge Apr 13, 2023
Nichtmal ChatGpT konnte mir diese Frage beantworten. DE Apr 4, 2023
Testing ChatGPT for potential sound design applications how to make "that" sound Feb 22, 2023
ChatGPT for Musicians Industry News Feb 17, 2023
Loading...