please let me know if you know any website or software that is the BEST in audio to midi separation
i tried several but they are not separating properly the midi data

 

I use Melodyne and Neutone as VSTs - also the Fadr website sometimes.

None of these render perfect results, but they get you very close.

 

NeuralNote do the pretty good job... you can play around with settings to gain fine results.
they have no internet page. giht hub have..
https://github.com/DamRsn/NeuralNote

 

i tried notegrabber by navie d, so good for real, but u have to draw manually what info/notes u want to export as midi with one click later... but melodyne, never doubt about use that!!!

 

Melodyne and RipX are very good, but if the piece of music isn't clean, then expect lots of ghost notes. Melodyne gives you a clearer picture of what's being played, then you can attempt to simply play it in instead of spending time cleaning it up, once you pick out few notes, you're almost there.

 

Somebody in the forum suggested a trick that helps, i forget who, so sorry i cant credit. The trick is to choke/ gate/ volume automate tha audio first so that the notes are short and clean, otherwise you get all of these random filler notes. With the choked notes you are more likely to get just the chords / notes you need. you will still need to tweak the midi by hand, but this helps a lot.

 

Without a doubt the best audio to midi converter is a transcriptionist musician.
Practice can make you one of them.

 

The Plugin Guy has something to say about NeuralNote.
Worth checking out the comments too.

 

And then there's KVR with a video on NeuralNote

https://www.kvraudio.com/product/neuralnote-by-dr-audio

 

Cleaning up the MIDI is definitely the answer. I was doing a hip hop mix with an organ sample that was just lackluster - had the feel but not the sonics. Wanted to lay a vsti underneath to supplement the sound. I put it in RipX and got the MIDI, but definitely had to clean it up. Melodyne would have been my default choice- tried RipX to put it through its paces, I was happy with the results.

 

Still Melodyne for me, but i've tried the others with Mac versions available and they are ok too.

To clean up some of the ghost notes you may get in it, you can put an Antares Auto-tune instance as an insert effect before Melodyne. If tails of notes are an issue, you can insert a Transient Designer plugin before Melodyne also. You just adjust the tails by adjusting the hold, decay, or sustain parameter of the transient designer. They can use various terms for the parameter to shorten notes, but it can help if notes run together.

If ghost notes are really all over the place in the Midi, adding a midi instrument and an arpeggiator with a very fast rate can help bounce a cleaner copy of the notes in the stem. Sometimes you have to experiment or play it yourself, as already suggested.

 

just adding the free samplab https://samplab.com/ i get pretty constant results from it especially if its a small loop