Hi, i made a track that got 1k + and counting, a peak time track posted it here track is called Choices and ppl keeps liking it and its getting attention, so i wanted to do another one,and so i did! and i am very unsure if this is any good,
Feel like i have too much going on, should i delete it or change it?

What is your opinion and feedback on this and the other, differences, and should i delete Voyage?
Is the first track ALOT better? The one called Choices.

 

Just never work for the trash can. It's in the nature of things that few things are very good and most are average but good.

You can see that in number 1 hits, sometimes a band has a number 1 hit to pay off their loans and earn money or become famous. But nobody can sit down and say I'm going to write a number 1 hit.

Just rename it version 1, version 2, version 3. You know your craft. Everything you do is listenable and danceable, keep it up....!

 

Sounds like it took you about 5 minutes on Suno.

 

Yes they can. Following the success of Doctorin’ The Tardis under the name The Timelords, the KLF wrote a book called The Manual (How To Have A Number One The Easy Way). They even offered a money-back guarantee to anybody who did not score a #1 single after meticulously following their zenarchistic instructions to the letter.

Austrian band Edelweiss famously followed the rules in the book and had an international hit with “Bring Me Edelweiss”. It was number 1 in six countries.

 

Yes, you are right - if only I had read your book when I was 17, I could have saved myself the hard work life.
Abba had number 9 hits in the charts.

 

Yes, but only if you'd have followed the instructions. The Manual even states you don't need to have any musical ability.

From the manual:

Coincidentally, both The JAMS (another KLF alias) and Eidelweiss both co-opted (ie stole) whole chunks of melodies from Abba.

Bring Me Eidelweiss sold over 5 million copies worldwide.

 

Are you trying to create your track by the consensus of random unknown Audiosexers?

If so, I suggest adding some yodelling.

 

Besides stealing whole chunks of melodies from Abba, those low and thieving Austrians stole the national flower of Switzerland, the noble white Edelweiss itself without as much as a passing thought.

 

thnx man, i had to ask for some help i dont know if its good after spending 2 days with it, become blind to the music... but thnx

 

and what is suno? It took me 2 days and i can make a track fully blown in a day some times, im not cutting any corners im just good, is that why you made your comment? should i be offended? anyway thnx

 

I need opinions on the track not the reason behind why it was made. its called feedack and i would like it. Is the song good or
bad?

 

What makes me (or anyone else on here) qualified to judge whether it's good or bad? Isn't it meaningless if I say it's the greatest thing I've ever heard or it's the biggest piece of shit?

Well there you go. Belief is everything. Proceed with the utmost confidence.

OK, yes. You should add yodelling.

 

Last edited: Feb 9, 2025 at 3:39 PM

Don't be so hard on yourself, take your time and not life, people are not robots and not hit machines.
So far things have been going well for you - you always have ups and downs.

Take a break every now and then and then tackle a song again with renewed energy.

 

Yeah good advice, ;) thanks i should wind down a bit, ive been making nonstop for some time now.

 

Well opinions helps me in what direction to go, ofc it doesnt change much but i was looking for feedback because when i listen to the track i think its ok, hard, but ok. I dont know what you or others think, is hard to listen to the track and then comment on the actual track? or is yodelling better? Yes yodelling should be in order here.

 

I think you should try it with yodelling. Just to see where it goes.

 

First of all, people who create something also need the appreciation of others. There is criticism that is positive or negative.
But you communicate and everyone is perceived as the musician, as the listener....!

 

Dude, if you check his Soundcloud, he posted a similar track like five years ago. Suno only popped up in 2023, as far as I know. So if he had the skills to make a track like this without AI back in 2019 or 2020, why the hell would he be using a robot now?

 

if you wouldnt jump around all the time and would go away from that mainroom supersaw shit which btw have also zero signs of an own vibe and style , then....

 

Because it is "too quick", which is in fact in the title of the thread. Unlike others here, I do not care who uses AI because it is going to happen.

When I see an interview with David Guetta on NBCNEWS, and he says "if I can use it, i'm going to."; why should some artist spend many more days, weeks, or even months to do a track like they did in 2019 or whatever; just to make the same thing again. That's the purpose of using a template you have developed in your own DAW.

That said, if you knew more about what Suno cranks out, you would know there are tells in its output, which make it very easy to identify. It's not very great at mixing, or mastering. It uses that same right to left auto-pan in every EDM track. It's basically the exact same thing as the last thread where he was posting about how to use a clipper on the master and told me that he is using Standard Clip. He did not know CTZ strategy then and he does not still. That's OK, because neither does Suno. Let's ping @curtified and maybe he can listen.

If you do not like that someone says a track you post sounds like you just used an AI and care, all you ever have to do is post the DAW project file, or even just a small un-rendered portion of it. Not stems, because that can just as easily be separated after you download it from an AI. If you are considering "deleting it" already, then you should have no worries about posting the DAW files.

None of that will happen, and you already know it.