I win...more to come

 

10 songs that mean a lot to me : In no particular order!

01. Surf's Up (Brian Wilson Original Version)
02. Find The River (REM)
03. Chimes Of Freedom (Bob Dylan)
04. The Logical Song (Supertramp)
05. Morning Has Broken (Cat Stevens)
06. Artificial Man (The Kinks)
07. Shangri-La (ELO)
08. Fake Plastic Trees (Radiohead)
09. Brainwashed (George Harrison)
10. Into The Mystic (Van Morrison)

A Few Honourable Mentions:

The Final Cut (Pink Floyd)
In Dreams (Roy Orbison)
Nowhere Man (The Beatles)
Shangri-La (The Kinks)
Southern Accents (Tom Petty)
Stay [Faraway, So Close] (U2)
Take It To The Limit (The Eagles)
Family Tree (Gerry Rafferty)
The Famous Final Scene (Bob Seger)

It's so hard to cut it down to a top 10 really so I had to add a few!

These are songs that tug at my heartstrings for personal reasons.

Great Thread OP!

 

Yeah It's well worth checking out other favourites here! Some of them may end up on my own list!
Great Post

 

The Logical Song (Supertramp) seems like a common thread in this thread

 

I guess a lot of people identify with the lyrics and sentiment.

 

In No Particular Order



Stevie Wonder - Visions
Prince - If I Was Ur Girlfriend
The Beatles - In My Life
David Bowie - Fame
John Lennon - Imagine
Joni Mitchell - Clouds
Steely Dan - Aja
Ohio Players - Skin Tight
Tom Browne - Bye Gone
Gregory Isaacs & Prince Far I - Uncle Joe

This Should Be Top 25 Because there so much more to add

Black Uhuru - Shine Eye Gal
Ella Fitzgerald - How High The Moon (Live)
Stan Getz feat Joao Gilberto - Agua De Marco
Weather Report - River People
Capleton - Who Dem
Donny Hathaway - A Song For You
James Brown - Say It Loud
Rick James - Standing On The Top
Africa Bambaataa and the Soul Sonic Force - Planet Rock
Burning Spear - Hail H.I.M
Yabby You Trinity & King Tubby - Jah Vengeance
Wailing Soul & Scientist - Kingdom Rise Kingdom Fall
Devon Iron & Lee Perry - When Jah Come
Steel Pulse - Prediction
Chaz Jankle - Ai No Corrida

No It Has 2 B Top 50






PEACE

 

Last edited: Jun 21, 2019

Top thread!
last album: Bowie / Blackstar, impressive musicians, impressive Bowie recordered voice.
I have to much songs or compositions to make me cray.....
Requiem / Mozart
Stely Dan / Aja
N.Yung, D.Crosby (first solo album), CSN & Y
Prince / Sign of the time
Motown collections songs
Radiohead / Reckoner
Stranglers / Feline
Bach / Cello suite
Compay Segundo / Antologia
B.Marley / Congo and so much jamaican bands
Lucio Dalla one of the best from Italy!
Keit Jarret Trio
Cesaria Evora
......

i can write hours and hours......great to read your choices...thank you!

 

Love this one, too.

 

So baffling - not one song composed by AI in these lists - obviously we're all deaf

 

1 post malone sunflower
2 post malone sunflower
3 post malone sunflower
4 post malone sunflower
5 post malone sunflower
6 post malone sunflower
7 post malone sunflower
8 post malone sunflower
9 post malone sunflower
10 post malone sunflower

 

My top ten rock / metal songs. I deliberately ommitted other genres and traditions I love (classical, Jazz, electronic, Greek music etc.)

Pink Floyd / Shine on you crazy diamond
Leonard Cohen / Famous blue raincoat
Leonard Cohen / Master Song
Opeth / Dirge for November
Emperor / I am the black wizards
Anathema / Parisienne moonlight
Eloy / The sun song
Eagles / Hotel California
Sting / Fragile
Pink Floyd / Time

 

Not any particular songs but David gilmour's guitar play makes me wanna cry.. A true maestro who can play with your emotions....

 

In no particular order...
There would be so many...

 

I hate to be the rain on your parade, and even though I like the idea of this kind of thread and the fact you are all having a great/proud/emotional time making your lists - no one cares - I have read some of your lists, but without insight and reasons they don't look any different. Enjoy yourselves anyway!

 

Thank you you are the only one with Mozart´s Requiem on the list.

i would recommend everybody to listen Mozart´s Requiem conducted by Karl Böhm or if you like it slower by Sergiu Celibidache.

for me this is the purest music

this thread is great, thank you all.

P.S. look also for this guy philipp jaroussky

 

Me too. The only other choral work that really hits me on that level is Bach's 'Mass In B Minor" - especially 'Dona Nobis Pacem' (which begins about 6' 55''...):

 

Last edited: Jan 7, 2020

Those two Cohen Songs are Killers and how about Ballad of the absent mare or stranger song ?

 

Thanks to @Yellow Raven (and all posters) for the thread. Even if I'm familiar with 90% of the items, the other 10% being recommended by musicians that care about stuff means I'm bound to find some nice new goodies exploring what's been listed in here.

Not sure what being cynical added to this thread but I'll take your "insight and reasons" comment as a positive suggestion.
So, instead of a favourites top ten (which I wouldn't know how to compile)... here's just a few tracks as examples for me to woffle about.

What grabs my attention?
[1] is it the 'listen to ME' musician-performer-ego (and who cares what they play)?
[2] is it the writing-composition (and who cares who plays it)?
[3] is it the lyrical poetry (and who cares about the soundtrack)?
[4] is it something that just grabs me by the balls?
Could be any, or all, or a mixture, of the above - according to mood.

Examples and comments
[1] The 'listen to ME' musician-performer-ego
Some musical egos have great 'feel' and 'passion' even if they don't play that well.
Some musical egos play virtuoso level and bore me to death.
Some manage to be virtuoso plus feel plus passion and then it's really magic.
Here's an example that I think is magic
Joe Satriani - Made of Tears

[2] When the writing-composition is the main feature
Three versions of Claire De Lune, Piano, Orchestra, Guitar. In all three cases the musicians are obviously brilliant. They are NOT pushing their egos up front saying 'hey listen to me'. Almost the opposite, they're trying to keep out of the way and let the composer's work breathe through their fabulous skills. And if a composer (Debussy) can assemble a bunch of notes that are as brilliant as Claire De Lune, then that is what I want the musicians to do, leave their personalities somewhere else and let me hear the magic of the composition.
All three versions are (inevitably) beautiful. When a composition is this good, I would even enjoy (but not prefer) a machine playing it!
Claire de Lune
Piano version
Orchestral version
Acoustic Guitar version

[3] Lyrical poetry (and who cares about the soundtrack)
An entirely personal bias... for me, more often than not, lyrics get in the way. I love the human voice as an instrument, but I don't care much for lyrical poetry in my music. So no examples from me here. I respect that lots of people feel exactly the opposite

[4] Grabs me by the balls
I wouldn't call any of these 'touching my soul' but I love anything that can can just hit me in the gut and make me pay attention.
Band Maid - Real Existence
They sing in Japanese; no idea what they're singing about, don't care, love it.
Carmina Burana
Don't care what they're singing about either - the voices are just awesome.

 

Last edited: Jun 23, 2019

The ddoctor argument is not unfounded.
So here is the explanation of my choices.

Bach BWV 1043 and Vivaldi's Stabat mater: The perfection of baroque writing. The search for a world order that speaks to me even if this order is a vain attempt to deal with the chaos of life.
Led Zeppelin: a reinterpretation and reappropriation of the blues that touches perfection.
Yes : The fusion of rock and classical influences served by outstanding musicians and singer.
The enchanted flute... a staging and a performer who, in my humble opinion, touches perfection. Not to mention the brilliant composer...
Joe Cocker and Marianne Faithfull: the encounter between exceptional compositions and equally exceptional performers.
David Bowie and Jacques Brel: magnificent and poignant lyrics served by perfect arrangements and poignant performers.

To be perfectly honest, I could put a lot of other things in this top 10 and my choices could even vary from one day to the next.