Hi everybody.

Just tried to check the differencies between the two DAW in regard of the soundquality/sounddifferencies.
And want to ask as if i made something wrong, or if anyone has the same experience.

I loaded a VSTi (NI's FM8) and rendered 2 noteprogressions into a wavefile, both in Ableton Live and also in Magix Sequoia
Then loaded the two wavefiles into Ableton Live (unwarped) and dephased one file with the utilitytool. So i hoped the both sounds would cancel eachother. But they didn't. And if you zoom into these wavefiles you can see that they are different. So i think that there are differencies between the two DAW's. Anyone can confirm this experiment or did i do somthing wrong? Maybe people with other DAW's can repeat and report their results here too.

Greets.

 

are they in phase? maybe startingpoint of wave is diff
is the fm-8 sound moodulated? when it is a "moving" sound of course you will have diff waves with every recording

 

No, its just a standart sinewave, and both made inphase.

 

try this:

1. record the same fm8 sound in ableton or sequoia internally -twice-

2. put one of them on a new track under the first one

3. compare them if the waves are in phase by zooming really close

 

Yes, I would suggest to first check if FM8 output is not unique each time, compare Live with Live first.

 

http://src.infinitewave.ca/


here is SRC comparrison of pretty much every DAW seq out there .

Enjoy guys

 

holy fuck this is nice!! really love the scientific approach!

 

me to, where to learn that stuff - i want to understand it